Page 1 of 1

Duplicate notes in MIDI edit

Posted: Tue Oct 05, 2010 9:44 am
by trevorallan
I'm having problems with unwanted duplicate MIDI notes. When I select a MIDI note (or group of MIDI notes) in the graphic editor window and move them either in pitch or in time, I get duplicates as if I had held down the option key. They don't disappear when I Deflam. They aren't selectable either. They show up as exact duplicates in the event information window, but again aren't selectable or erasable. If I move one (sometimes this seems randomly possible) the duplicate note behind it still sits there unmovable and unerasable.

The notes disappear if I record over the selection, and that's the only way I can get rid of them. I've tried using the trackpad instead of the mouse and also a different keyboard. Same behaviour.

Am I missing something obvious? This is slowing me down something terrible.

Thanks

Re: Duplicate notes in MIDI edit

Posted: Tue Oct 05, 2010 10:06 am
by Tritonemusic
Instead of De Flam, try Remove Duplicates (pg. 970 in the DP7 User Guide).

Re: Duplicate notes in MIDI edit

Posted: Tue Oct 05, 2010 3:19 pm
by trevorallan
666 wrote:Instead of De Flam, try Remove Duplicates (pg. 970 in the DP7 User Guide).
Thanks, but it doesn't work. I can't select the duplicates in any window. I can select a region in the Graphic Editor containing the duplicate notes, and can see them both selected in the events list (as long as the selected region contains ordinary non-duplicated notes before and after). I apply Remove Duplicates and nothing happens. I can erase everything in the region, but then I lose the other notes as well.

?!?!?


And this is only one aspect of this. When I move a normal note in time or pitch it leaves an unselectable ghost duplicate at the original location. This duplicate appears to be a product of the 'select and move' procedure - the duplicate isn't there before I try the move.

?!?!?

These wierdnesses are occurring nearly all of the time. Why not all the time?

Re: Duplicate notes in MIDI edit

Posted: Tue Oct 05, 2010 9:07 pm
by keybored0
Most interesting...I had my share of duplicate sounding notes but could never see them, and remove duplicates, etc had no effect. But the question here is: Is there a volume surge/increase as a result of these ghost copies? Or is this merely a graphic phenomenon? If the former, you really should report this to MOTU.

Re: Duplicate notes in MIDI edit

Posted: Wed Oct 06, 2010 3:39 am
by williemyers
trevorallan wrote:
666 wrote:Instead of De Flam, try Remove Duplicates (pg. 970 in the DP7 User Guide).
Thanks, but it doesn't work. I can't select the duplicates in any window. I can select a region in the Graphic Editor containing the duplicate notes, and can see them both selected in the events list (as long as the selected region contains ordinary non-duplicated notes before and after). I apply Remove Duplicates and nothing happens. I can erase everything in the region, but then I lose the other notes as well.

?!?!?


And this is only one aspect of this. When I move a normal note in time or pitch it leaves an unselectable ghost duplicate at the original location. This duplicate appears to be a product of the 'select and move' procedure - the duplicate isn't there before I try the move.

?!?!?

These wierdnesses are occurring nearly all of the time. Why not all the time?

try this post
http://www.motunation.com/forum/viewtop ... 15#p336933" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
it may be exactly what's causing your situ and it's and easy fix!

Re: Duplicate notes in MIDI edit

Posted: Wed Oct 06, 2010 5:31 am
by trevorallan
Fixed in one fell swoop! I owe you a few hours somewhere down the line.
Many Thanks!

Re: Duplicate notes in MIDI edit

Posted: Wed Oct 06, 2010 6:47 am
by williemyers
trevorallan wrote:Fixed in one fell swoop! I owe you a few hours somewhere down the line.
Many Thanks!
damn...I just came back from the UK! tell me which town/village you're in and I'll tell you which CAMRA pub I would've met you in!