bayswater wrote: ↑Wed Apr 06, 2022 6:20 pm
I know the experience. People send me things they’ve written in Logic, or GB. I usually have to export to DP and the MIDI export is always an adventure. There are a few things in Logic I really like and wish DP would so, and I’ve started many projects in Logic, but never finished one. Every time, there was a dead end. Sometimes I go to a list with Logic gurus and ask how to deal with it, and the reply is “ya, that doesn’t work”. Yet there are smart people who manage to make good music in Logic.
OMG That is
exactly my experience with Logic - every time! I'm just finishing up a large album project now, which began in Logic. I started beat-mapping the rubato playing of the client (who has never once turned the click on), only to discover that whilst the Beat-mapping in Logic would be amazing if it actually did what it's supposed to, it just doesn't, and you can spend hours mapping a section only to have Logic lose it all and act like you never did any - I ended up porting the entire project over to DP so that I could use the ever reliable 'Adjust Beats'.
I love the Logic forum - "I'd like Logic to just export the MIDI tracks as MIDI tracks in a MIDI file" … "Nup, you can't do that, it exports the
regions as separate MIDI tracks, deal with it".
"What about renumbering the Bars so that I can have a count in, and still start the music at bar 1, so that it lines up with my score" … "Nup, can't do that either".
"What if I want the MIDI file to export only to the end point of my cue"…"Nup, despite you entering in an 'End' point for the project, Logic will randomly export 2576 bars of empty space at the end of your MIDI file just so that Sibelius runs slow until you remove them".
I did actually finish a project on Logic, .... once … several years ago,… but my experience on that job with the awful audio editing interface made me swear that I would never attempt it again.
In the last few years I have had use just about everything in the course of my work; Logic, Pro Tools, Cubase, Reason, Studio One, etc. and every time I open up DP it's like coming home.
Mac OSX 10.14.6. Mac Pro. RME FF800. DP 9.52