USB or Firewire Interface

[westla]

I'm looking to get a audio/MIDI interface for my Powerbook. And I was wondering what's better USB or Firewire?

I've been in the music biz for years, but I've always (and still currently) have a PowerMac with PCI interfaces. I never ventured into USB or Firewire.

But now I have a Powerbook and want a interface for it. This isn't to replace my studio (I still do 99% of my work on my G5/2408mk3, etc), but ocasionally I'll need my assistant to also work on the Powerbook, or maybe do small recording outside my studio.

I've been looking at:

Lexicon Omega
Macke Spike
Focusrite Saffire

Any input would be appreciated.

<small>[ June 15, 2005, 05:49 PM: Message edited by: westla ]</small>

[chrispick]

Originally posted by westla:
I'm looking to get a audio/MIDI interface for my Powerbook. And I was wondering what's better USB or Firewire?

I've never used a USB interface, but I've had impeccable performances with firewire interfaces. Given that firewire has faster, wider bandwidth and runs off its own card, I think it's the wiser choice.

[builder]

Only get a USB interface if you enjoy headaches and other associated pains from frustration.

Firewire all the way.

[westla]

I thought USB 2.0 had more bandwidth compared to firewire 400, is this correct?

[chrispick]

Originally posted by westla:
I thought USB 2.0 had more bandwidth compared to firewire 400, is this correct?

Actually yes, you're right, at least theorically. USB 2 is said to rate at 480 Mbps while Firewire 400 rates at 400 Mbps. But, in real world application, Firewire 400 is still faster.

Check this article:

USB 2.0 versus Firewire 400

or this one...

Another example

<small>[ June 16, 2005, 10:44 AM: Message edited by: heavypick ]</small>

[westla]

Thanks for the great info Heavypick! I guess it's obvious I should go with a Firewire intrface.

[chrispick]

Originally posted by westla:
Thanks for the great info Heavypick! I guess it's obvious I should go with a Firewire intrface.

You bet, man. Good luck with your purchase.