Portato? Staccato under a slur?

Discussions about composing, arranging, orchestration, songwriting, theory, etc...

Moderators: Frodo, FMiguelez, MIDI Life Crisis

Forum rules
Discussions about composing, arranging, orchestration, songwriting, theory and the art of creating music in all forms from orchestral film scores to pop/rock.
Post Reply
User avatar
stubbsonic
Posts: 4600
Joined: Fri Dec 22, 2006 12:56 pm
Primary DAW OS: MacOS
Contact:

Portato? Staccato under a slur?

Post by stubbsonic »

I just saw this yesterday in an older trombone method book. I was wondering what the consensus is about how to interpret this in playing. Are the notes to be "slightly articulated"? Or separated while still maintaining the flow of the phrase?

Wikepedia suggests the former.

Any thoughts?
M1 MBP; OS 12, FF800, DP 11.3, Kontakt 7, Reaktor 6, PC3K7, K2661S, iPad6, Godin XTSA, Two Ibanez 5 string basses (1 fretted, 1 fretless), FM3, SY-1000, etc.

http://www.jonstubbsmusic.com
User avatar
Kurt Cowling
Posts: 384
Joined: Mon Oct 18, 2004 10:01 pm
Primary DAW OS: MacOS
Location: Milwaukee, WI

Re: Portato? Staccato under a slur?

Post by Kurt Cowling »

I'm not a wind player, but I'll bite.

I've come to think of staccato as having to do with how you stop the note, not so much about how you start the note. How about slurring to the second note and then stopping the air with the tongue?

This brings up another question... I had a trombone player tell me that they never really slur. Even when slurs are marked they slightly articulate so that it doesn't sound like glissando constantly. This must be unique to trombone since the slide will always need some time to move.
DP 11.1, Monterey, 2021 MacBook Pro M1-Max, 2017 iMac Retina 5K 27-inch, Omnisphere 2, Trilian, Stylus RMX, EZ Drummer 2, MachFive 3.11, Real Guitar2, Real Strat, Sample Modeling trumpet, saxes, trombone, Fr Horn/Tuba. Audio Modeling clarinets, double reeds, flutes, strings, Kontakt 6, Flux Pure Limiter 3, PSP Vintage Warmer, PSP MixPack, PSP StereoPack, PSP Impressor, Altiverb 7, Izotope RX8 Standard, Yamaha S-90ES, Yamaha MOXF-8, Yamaha MX60, Sibelius subscription, Adobe CC and Motion 5.
User avatar
Phil O
Posts: 7231
Joined: Thu Jul 28, 2005 10:01 pm
Primary DAW OS: MacOS
Location: Scituate, MA

Re: Portato? Staccato under a slur?

Post by Phil O »

I'm mildly dyslexic and at first glance thought it said potato.

Anyway, I've seen this notation before and was told by a friend who does a lot of orchestration that it's primarily used for strings, but some wind instruments can approximate the effect. Of course, that's just one person's take on it. :?

Phil
DP 11.23, 2020 M1 Mac Mini [9,1] (16 Gig RAM), Mac Pro 3GHz 8 core [6,1] (16 Gig RAM), OS 14.3.1/11.6.2, Lynx Aurora (n) 8tb, MOTU 8pre-es, MOTU M6, MOTU 828, Apogee Rosetta 800, UAD-2 Satellite, a truckload of outboard gear and plug-ins, and a partridge in a pear tree.
User avatar
MIDI Life Crisis
Posts: 26254
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 10:01 pm
Primary DAW OS: MacOS
Contact:

Re: Portato? Staccato under a slur?

Post by MIDI Life Crisis »

Look here:

http://music.stackexchange.com/question ... d-staccato

Often in Mozart piano music you see this (staccato notes with "slurs") which is more of a phrasing indication where the notes are played for their full value (as if soured) but a tiny space between the notes is introduced. You can think of them as dashes with dots if that help (I.E. full value with a tiny staccato type pause but without accenting the staccato so the phrase is still connected in a legato sense but has a more elegant execution. Bad piano teachers have a very hard time describing that. All they need to do is play it for the student to understand, but again, bad teachers are often bad players and they may not understand the concept. The key thing is to not disturb the evenness of the phrase with overly accented staccato.

In traffic it might look like this... mind the lorry and the pedestrians.

Image
2013 Mac Pro 32GB RAM

OSX 10.14.6; DP 10; Track 16; Finale 26, iPad Pro, et al

MIDI LIFE CRISIS
User avatar
stubbsonic
Posts: 4600
Joined: Fri Dec 22, 2006 12:56 pm
Primary DAW OS: MacOS
Contact:

Re: Portato? Staccato under a slur?

Post by stubbsonic »

I got the impression that Portato was a string articulation. In response to your suggestion, I'm not just talking about a pair of slurred notes where the second is staccato. I'm talking about a more than two notes and multiple staccato markings under a longer legato phrase.

I play trombone. And your friend is not entirely correct. Trombones can slur some pairs of notes. Not to get too weedy, but here's how it works.

A trombone has roughly 8 or so pitches in one position (depending on the player's range). They follow the harmonic series, so lower pitches are further apart and get closer together as you go up. Lowering the slide by one position drops those pitches by a half-step. If the two slurred notes are within the same "register"-- i.e. the pitch of a specific harmonic and all the related notes produced by moving the slide in or out - then you have to lightly tongue notes within that same register to hide the slide movement.

But a significant number of natural slurs can occur by crossing to a register above or below. When done right, a listener can't tell the difference between a natural slur and the carefully tongued one. This light-tonguing interrupts the air about as much as a valve or rotor would. And speaking of a rotor, trombones with triggers provide more non-tongued slur options.

Sorry for that diversion. I don't get to talk trombone very much.


PHIL O: You say potato, I say Portato.

MLS: Your definition was more what I was "intuiting". And that is how I described it to the student, while making it clear that I was merely guessing and would need to consult the experts. Thanks. That's well worded and very clear.

Thanks all.
M1 MBP; OS 12, FF800, DP 11.3, Kontakt 7, Reaktor 6, PC3K7, K2661S, iPad6, Godin XTSA, Two Ibanez 5 string basses (1 fretted, 1 fretless), FM3, SY-1000, etc.

http://www.jonstubbsmusic.com
User avatar
MIDI Life Crisis
Posts: 26254
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 10:01 pm
Primary DAW OS: MacOS
Contact:

Re: Portato? Staccato under a slur?

Post by MIDI Life Crisis »

Who's MLS... LOL :rofl:

Thanks, I know what you meant. MIDI Life? Seriously?
2013 Mac Pro 32GB RAM

OSX 10.14.6; DP 10; Track 16; Finale 26, iPad Pro, et al

MIDI LIFE CRISIS
User avatar
mikehalloran
Posts: 15133
Joined: Sun Jan 25, 2009 5:08 pm
Primary DAW OS: MacOS
Location: Sillie Con Valley

Re: Portato? Staccato under a slur?

Post by mikehalloran »

Sorry for that diversion. I don't get to talk trombone very much.
In 9th grade, I had a band teacher who played the 'bone. He often stopped rehearsal to teach the section how to do slurs properly. Thanks for taking me back.

Here's the Wiki for Portato

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portato
DP 11.31; 828mkII FW, micro lite, M4, MTP/AV USB Firmware 2.0.1
2023 Mac Studio M2 8TB, 192GB RAM, OS Sonoma 14.4, USB4 8TB external, M-Audio AIR 192|14, Mackie ProFxv3 6/10/12; 2012 MBPs Catalina, Mojave
IK-NI-Izotope-PSP-Garritan-Antares, LogicPro X, Finale 27.4, Dorico 5.2, Notion 6, Overture 5, TwistedWave, DSP-Q 5, SmartScore64 Pro, Toast 20 Pro
User avatar
stubbsonic
Posts: 4600
Joined: Fri Dec 22, 2006 12:56 pm
Primary DAW OS: MacOS
Contact:

Re: Portato? Staccato under a slur?

Post by stubbsonic »

MIDI Life Crisis wrote:Who's MLS... LOL :rofl:
[/i]
I have no idea what I meant. I'm relatively certain I didn't mean "MIDI LIFE STYLES" of the rich and famous.

Mike, I saw the wiki entry (which is where I got the term), but it seems to differ from Mr. Style's definition. Wiki says don't separate them, but articulate them, and MLC's description says introduce a tiny space. I suppose they aren't really mutually exclusive. It sounds like the composer really wants the performer to express this ambiguity with great precision, to detach the notes, but still keep them joined. Smooth and connected, but not extra smooth and not truly connected.

Perhaps I should just say "remove the slurs and dots and play non-commitally".
M1 MBP; OS 12, FF800, DP 11.3, Kontakt 7, Reaktor 6, PC3K7, K2661S, iPad6, Godin XTSA, Two Ibanez 5 string basses (1 fretted, 1 fretless), FM3, SY-1000, etc.

http://www.jonstubbsmusic.com
User avatar
MIDI Life Crisis
Posts: 26254
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 10:01 pm
Primary DAW OS: MacOS
Contact:

Re: Portato? Staccato under a slur?

Post by MIDI Life Crisis »

The music is a reference point for interpretation. For every "precise" way of playing something there is an equally valid "interpretational" way of playing that thing another way. In most of the piano music I play that uses that notation (a lot in Mozart!) I see this in the slow movements. It's quite common. I think of it as a legato phrase where the continuity comes from precise control over the consistent volume connecting the notes, along with a "breathy" interpretation of the phrase. It's hard to put into words, and that's a good thing. :)
2013 Mac Pro 32GB RAM

OSX 10.14.6; DP 10; Track 16; Finale 26, iPad Pro, et al

MIDI LIFE CRISIS
User avatar
stubbsonic
Posts: 4600
Joined: Fri Dec 22, 2006 12:56 pm
Primary DAW OS: MacOS
Contact:

Re: Portato? Staccato under a slur?

Post by stubbsonic »

That is very helpful, indeed.
M1 MBP; OS 12, FF800, DP 11.3, Kontakt 7, Reaktor 6, PC3K7, K2661S, iPad6, Godin XTSA, Two Ibanez 5 string basses (1 fretted, 1 fretless), FM3, SY-1000, etc.

http://www.jonstubbsmusic.com
User avatar
mhschmieder
Posts: 11282
Joined: Wed Jul 06, 2005 10:01 pm
Primary DAW OS: MacOS
Location: Annandale VA

Re: Portato? Staccato under a slur?

Post by mhschmieder »

I go along with what MLC said about staccato being in the context of overall legato PHRASING.

I play many winds (except brasswinds), but not many strings (primarily double bass, and occasionally cello). No formal training, unlike with winds, so I've had to learn through my own research.

What I see most often, is people equating detache bowing of strings with portato playing in winds. This comes up in many sources but doesn't mean it's the final word. I think about this now and then but am not convinced.

I suppose if one gets back to these articulations being in the context of legato phrasing, it makes sense, as all of these articulations essentially leave the phrasing and dynamics untouched but affect mostly note length and note attack (to a lesser extent).

Articulations that would NOT be considered part of legato phrasing would be things like sforzando, tzigane (well, actually, that's debatable based on context), and probably certain crescendos and decrescendos. Yet each of those may have some comparisons in note attack to staccato or portato/sustain.

Pizzicato is a funny one, because it means something different for upright bass than the other strings. For upright, it does NOT involve plucking strings with two or more fingers. Possibly this is due to the stronger influence of the Viol family background for that instrument. This is true for both jazz and classical as far as I know.
iMac 27" 2017 Quad-Core Intel i5 (3.8 GHz, 64 GB), OSX 13.6.1, MOTU DP 11.31, iZotope RX 10
RME Babyface Pro FS, Radial JDV Mk5, Hammond XK-4, Moog Voyager

Eugenio Upright, 60th Anniversary P-Bass, USA Geddy Lee J-Bass, Yamaha BBP35
Select Strat, 70th Anniversary Esquire, Johhny Marr Jaguar, 57 LP, Danelectro 12
Eastman T486RB, T64/V, Ibanez PM2, D'angelico Deluxe SS Bari, EXL1
Guild Bari, 1512 12-string, M20, Martin OM28VTS, Larivee 0040MH
User avatar
mhschmieder
Posts: 11282
Joined: Wed Jul 06, 2005 10:01 pm
Primary DAW OS: MacOS
Location: Annandale VA

Re: Portato? Staccato under a slur?

Post by mhschmieder »

In Bach's time, notation was almost just a way of defining the basic structure, like a jazz chart that people blow over for their solos.

Things got ever more formal as composers sought more control over the performance of their works and as music itself went from rich royal hosts to a more varied source of benefactors and a broader and more public audience.

So, by the early twentieth century, there was almost no room left for personal expression or interpretation, in some works.

Another example is piano pedaling, which was always left to the discretion of the performer, until maybe the Impressionist period where it so closely defined very specific intent and mood at each point and thus was marked in the scores.

Regardless, some performers and conductors choose to ignore what they want to, and no one's going to put them in jail for that, revoke their license, or change the royalties equation -- even if they add music or ideas of their own to the basic work.
iMac 27" 2017 Quad-Core Intel i5 (3.8 GHz, 64 GB), OSX 13.6.1, MOTU DP 11.31, iZotope RX 10
RME Babyface Pro FS, Radial JDV Mk5, Hammond XK-4, Moog Voyager

Eugenio Upright, 60th Anniversary P-Bass, USA Geddy Lee J-Bass, Yamaha BBP35
Select Strat, 70th Anniversary Esquire, Johhny Marr Jaguar, 57 LP, Danelectro 12
Eastman T486RB, T64/V, Ibanez PM2, D'angelico Deluxe SS Bari, EXL1
Guild Bari, 1512 12-string, M20, Martin OM28VTS, Larivee 0040MH
User avatar
stubbsonic
Posts: 4600
Joined: Fri Dec 22, 2006 12:56 pm
Primary DAW OS: MacOS
Contact:

Re: Portato? Staccato under a slur?

Post by stubbsonic »

Fascinating stuff!

I suppose in any context, I could ask, "Has this been performed?" (As opposed to something from a method book), does the interpretation that I hear from recordings make musical sense to me? And most importantly, "What does the music itself suggest?"

Your point about a composer wanting to micromanage the interpretation of their notation is fascinating. I've been there with some things I've made where I have some specific ideas about which notes should be short and how long some notes should be. It's because SOME phrases exist in my imagination quite complete and I so enjoy hearing them do that particular maneuver.

Thanks all for your input. Truly fun.
M1 MBP; OS 12, FF800, DP 11.3, Kontakt 7, Reaktor 6, PC3K7, K2661S, iPad6, Godin XTSA, Two Ibanez 5 string basses (1 fretted, 1 fretless), FM3, SY-1000, etc.

http://www.jonstubbsmusic.com
User avatar
MIDI Life Crisis
Posts: 26254
Joined: Wed May 18, 2005 10:01 pm
Primary DAW OS: MacOS
Contact:

Re: Portato? Staccato under a slur?

Post by MIDI Life Crisis »

mhschmieder wrote:In Bach's time, notation was almost just a way of defining the basic structure, like a jazz chart that people blow over for their solos.
Now we're playing in my ballpark... LOL ...don't even get me started.
2013 Mac Pro 32GB RAM

OSX 10.14.6; DP 10; Track 16; Finale 26, iPad Pro, et al

MIDI LIFE CRISIS
Post Reply